medRxiv

Case fatality rates for COVID-19 are higher than case fatality rates for motor vehicle accidents for individuals over 40 years of age

At a glance

COVID-19 case fatality was 1.5 times motor-vehicle-accident fatality at ages 40–49 and 29.4 times higher above age 80; the direction reversed at ages 20–29.

The research question

How did early-pandemic COVID-19 fatality compare with a familiar accidental risk across age groups?

Overview

Age-stratified comparisons placed COVID-19 among the leading U.S. causes of death during its first pandemic year. The comparison was designed to communicate how sharply COVID-19 risk increased with age, not to equate unlike exposure definitions.

Study design & methods

National mortality and case estimates were used to compare annual mortality causes and age-stratified case fatality for COVID-19 with fatality among people involved in motor-vehicle accidents.

Principal findings

For adults 40 and older, COVID-19 was the third leading cause in the reported period at 325 deaths per 100,000. Relative case fatality was 1.5 (95% CI 1.3–1.7) at ages 40–49 and 29.4 (23.2–35.7) above 80; vehicle accidents were 4.5 times higher at ages 20–29. For adults 40 and older, COVID-19 was the third leading cause in the reported period at 325 deaths per 100,000. Relative case fatality was 1.5 (95% CI 1.3–1.7) at ages 40–49 and 29.4 (23.2–35.7) above 80; vehicle accidents were 4.5 times higher at ages 20–29.

Limitations & interpretation

The denominators, exposure opportunities and reporting systems differ substantially, so the analogy is communicative rather than causal. Estimates are specific to the pre-vaccine early pandemic. The denominators, exposure opportunities and reporting systems differ substantially, so the analogy is communicative rather than causal. Estimates are specific to the pre-vaccine early pandemic. Preprint

Publication type and venue follow the original nference listing. Read the original paper for full methods, analyses, and interpretation. View source listing.

Keep exploring.

All publications
Your next question could change everything.

What will you
discover next?

Let’s find out
Ideas are connected. Your next discovery starts here.